ASP.NET vs PHP: Which One To Choose and Why For App Development?

By Alka Singh
November 26, 2019 | 375 Views

Latest Industry insights to keep you updated on the latest happenings.

Businesses have no choice but to move to the online world. Even an entrepreneur today thinks of launching online first then setting up things in the offline space.

However, the road ahead has not remained as smooth as it was earlier. Application development processes are something that is evolving continuously due to the influencing factors like version updates in programming languages, frameworks, and libraries, and then is the emerging programming languages, frameworks, and libraries.

Even after receiving a bundle of updates, innovative libraries, and framework support, the debate for using ASP.NET vs PHP has not seen an end.

Both technologies have always emerged stronger and give a neck to neck competition to each other for the title ‘The Best’. So let’s not waste too much time here, and jump into the two dominating technologies and find which one is best to choose for app development.

But, first, understand both ASP.NET & PHP.

 

PHP & Its Business Use-Cases

PHP or Hypertext Preprocessor is a high level, dynamic, and scripting language. It is widely used in web page development and web services on the server-side. A well-known server-side scripting language, PHP is often used instead of Python.

PHP has witnessed backlog since the beginning as it does not utilize a ‘managed code system’, thus considered less secure, however, it allows developers to be more creative while writing programs.

Using PHP, developers can design web elements in a unique way that is not dictated by the managed code system of the .NET family. Additionally, PHP is flexible due to being open source. It can run on any platform.

 

Advantages of PHP

 

1Gather user information with the use of forms
2Collect information automatically from various web pages and from all over the Internet
3Create a membership option for your website
4Generate dynamic files and webpages
5Track users with the help of cookies
6Add any kind of dynamic function you can come up with
7Create desktop applications
8PHP has some incredibly useful text processing features
9It’s incredibly easy to find hosting for PHP
10PHP has a wide range of powerful built-in functions

 

ASP.NET & Its Business Use-Cases

ASP.NET is a web development framework by Microsoft and typically uses C#. The framework requires developers to work by certain rules such as the managed code framework which governs the run-time of code execution. 

When using ASP.NET, developers don’t enjoy a lot of freedom as they have to write an app with the “rule-based” nature of .NET. But allows them to use modules, which is sometimes forced by the managed code system, to work together. This, in turn, makes development, testing & deploying apps much more seamless and quicker.

Since developing robust sites utilizing the ASP.NET system, it does not require extensive code from scratch – and ASP.NET can be integrated with powerful Microsoft systems, such as Microsoft SharePoint for App Development, management, and deployment across the board – web development with the framework is often less resource-heavy.

As has been noted, ASP.NET Core, formerly known as ASP.NET VNext, allows cross-platform development as well, which mitigates the costly Windows licenses required for the .NET Framework and Microsoft Servers. 

 

Advantages of ASP.NET

 

1It supports flexible programming due to carrying object-oriented features
2It supports ‘separation of concern’ as follows MVC patterns in app development. It also simplifies maintaining the app
3It promotes test-driven development, thus unit testing enables developers to be more productive
4Has a mature framework due to having task-based libraries. Whether it requires to edit an image or XML, developers share ample of time doing things.
5Its event-driven programming nature promotes the simple app development process
6It supports many different languages such as C#, C, C++, Jscript.Net, VB. Net and a lot more. Developers can choose to write code in their preferred programming skills

 

Both languages have their pros, they also have their fair share of cons

 

ASP.NETPHP
High upkeep costsVarious security flaws
Hard to Understand the Application FlowNot so good for developing desktop applications
PHP has a weak type

 

It’s easy to compare one language to another, but the debate never ends until businesses find the answer to “which one should I choose for the application development?”

Besides, ASP.Net and PHP have not seen a major drop in popularity and adoption.

PHP, with 26.4% growth, has acquired 8th position as one of the most popular programming languages in Stackoverflow Developers Survey 2019While ASP.NET made the 4th position as one of the most popular web frameworks where it didn’t even make an appearance in the survey of 2018.

However, if we compare the market share of ASP.NET and PHP, the latter leads the way with huge numbers to report. One such report shared by similar tech.

php-vs-asp-net

PHP even has better usage coverage in multiple website categories. Just look at the stats below image. 

php better option for websites

In a general way, PHP is leading the way whereas ASP.NET has miles to cover.

Here, it is important to understand how ASP.NET has made it to Stackoverflow’s survey list if PHP has this sort of popularity and adoption.

This is where we have to adopt a different method to differentiate between ASP.NET vs PHP. 

As we mentioned earlier, PHP is a programming language whereas ASP.NET is a framework. Therefore, if we compare a framework to a framework i.e. ASP.NET to Laravel(it is the most advanced PHP powered framework today) we get completely different results. 

ASP.NET has approximately 2,417,820 websites whereas Laravel shrinks to only 123,513. Moreover, ASP.NET leads the way in terms of market share as well as website categories.

To shed some more light on ASP.NET vs PHP, it is also important to compare a programming language to a programming language i.e PHP vs C# (C# is a primarily used programming language in ASP.NET).

Let’s take a look at Google Trends’ report below

interest trend for php vs c

Over the past five years, PHP has been a more popular search term than C#.

C# is more widely used in NON-WEB applications than PHP, which is used as a general-purpose programming language. It is used for Windows phone apps, tools, and even cross-platform mobile frameworks (MONO).

C# is an object-oriented programming language whereas PHP is NOT.

Even with 31% growth, C# has attained 7th place in Stackoverflow 2019 survey and maintains a lead over PHP. Still, PHP is more popular and widely used over C#. 

To decide which technology, however, is suitable for application development, businesses have to decide the purpose of the project. 

 

Deciding on ASP.NET vs PHP for App Development?

There are several components that need to be considered to decide the tech stack for the website/application development. Almost every application/website requires to be scalable, quick in performance, provide security, ensure smooth functionality, look aesthetic, support seamless integrations and cost-effective.

Therefore, a company’s strategic plan should revolve around the following differentiation to align with the goals of the company. 

 

Major Difference b/w ASP & PHP 

 

 ASP.NETPHP
TypeWeb Application Framework and a Microsoft productServer-side scripting language. Used by Google, Facebook, Yahoo and more
SupportIdeal to build medium to large size enterprise appsWidely used to create small to medium-sized web solutions
SolutionsMajor focus on security and functionalitiesMore focused on client-facing, user interfaces
CommunityDedicated community with growing developersLarge size community
SecurityHighly SecureLess built-in security feature
SpeedDecent speed, fast enough for a desktop applicationNot suitable and slower for a desktop application
CustomizationLess prone to customizationAllows customization which can cause bugs, thus poor coding than .NET

 

However, a business must differentiate the two on the following parameters:

 

 ASP.NETPHP
CompatibilityASP.NET is made for windows platforms primarily, thus it has a heavy dependence on the platform. When it comes to using ASP.NET, it is important for developers to use Microsoft Visual Studio during the development process. PHP is compatible with different platforms such as Linux, UNIX, Windows and almost everything you would use it for. Therefore, PHP is supported by numerous IDE's available for free and paid as well.  
ScalabilityMicrosoft and Stackoverflow are built using ASP.NET and are highly scalable.Facebook and Wikipedia are PHP based websites, thus there is no doubt PHP can be your choice if you want it to choose. However, PHP is a more reliable choice if you want to develop a website through a content management system such as Drupal, Joomla, or Wordpress. 
PerformanceASP.Net gives complete control over the project including the writing of code and architecture implementation that defined the good performance of the website. PHP, yet also is faster. It is behind Facebook, Google, and Yahoo. 
Deployment TimeUsing ASP.NET involves a time-consuming process as ASP has to be complied with every time to ensure modifications in the code.  PHP is interpreted on the server, therefore it involves comparatively less time in deployment.

 

As we have seen, it is tough to differentiate between ASP.NET and PHP. Over time, PHP has received comprehensive community support. Thus, different frameworks and integrations are available to support it.

On the other hand, ASP.NET is a Microsoft product and is a standard framework that makes it popular among developers interested in building standard websites.

Then how would you decide which technology is best for their business?

To find the answer to that question, it is important to understand Who will be in contact with your content?’ Both the technologies considered best to use the following:

  • Commercial Web Sites
  • General Web Development
  • REST Based Web Services
  • Desktop Applications
  • Server Scripting

 

Consideration between ASP.NET and PHP wouldn’t end until businesses shed light on the website whether it is client-facing or internally/business-facing. As mentioned on PHP’s official website, ‘PHP powers everything from your blog to the most popular websites in the world’.

PHP may benefit external websites more, whereas ASP.NET may better be left for business-facing websites/apps.

Let’s try to understand the importance of PHP and ASP.NET in security, optimization, performance, aesthetics, and functions. Also, understand how important these are for external and internal websites/apps.  

 

Client Facing Websites

PHP was originally innovated to enable more optimized and better-looking web page development. It comes with a set of tools that supports the developer’s creativity, thus a business gets better looking and better-performing websites.

Being so if we look closely, PHP is considered best to develop for more personal and business websites, including social media websites like Facebook uses PHP and refactored using HPHPi & HHVM.

PHP ensures the needs of externally-facing websites such as optimization, aesthetics, and performance.

 

Internal Websites

When a website/app needs to be developed for a business within a corporation’s intranet, then security and functionality become crucial along with integration with enterprise IT systems.

Due to being a managed code system, ASP.NET shines in providing enterprise solutions. ASP.NET secures code at run-time, as the framework lets the developer build the website keeping functionality in mind. ASP.NET is widely used for web services development and mostly websites deployed on windows systems and/or IIS.

As ASP.NET is a Microsoft product itself, integration of other Microsoft services with it greatly increase the workflow efficiency, productivity, and management of company operations/projects.

Though ASP.NET is not a good choice to build end product appearance as appealing as PHP, it definitely should be your choice while developing an internally-facing website/app to make it secure and highly functional. It can help personnel with the required resources to complete daily workflows/projects.

 

Cost Advantage?

We already know PHP is open-source and thus it is easy to declare it a winner when it comes to cost-effectiveness. ASP.NET is available for free to use, though for integration, hosting and other app requirements, Microsoft charges a fee for it.

Though, the fee charged by Microsoft is not high but when compared to free usage that PHP and its supportive technologies provide makes developers skeptical towards ASP.NET. 

ASP.NET has cost included, it doesn’t, however, stop developers from building a website with Microsoft’s framework. 

 

Wrapping Up

There are scenarios where PHP is the right choice while in other cases ASP.NET fits better. Before settling on the choice on which platform is progressively appropriate, you ought to ask the following things:

  • How much budget do you have for the project? (When low budget go for PHP, while on a healthy budget you have the option to go for ASP.NET)
  • Which of these technologies does your development team know better?
  • What are the prerequisites and end-user needs?

 

In the wake of responding to these basic questions, you ought to get a look at understanding which might be better for your business application.

It is very little either platform can’t achieve, henceforth you have to go a little deep to analyze the suitability of each language as opposed to their popularity.

RECOMMENDED

Monthly industry insights to keep you updated on latest happenings

Follow us on Twitter
Follow us on Facebook
Follow us on Linkedin